Fence Replacement vs. Repair – Decision Guide

Choosing between fence repair and replacement depends on several factors, including the fence’s age, damage severity, and future maintenance needs. Paramount Fence, a locally owned Illinois business, located in Batavia, IL with over 100 years of combined experience, offers expert advice to help you make the right choice.

When to Repair a Fence

Repairing your fence may be a good option if the damage is minor and localized.

• Small Damage – Issues like loose or damaged boards or rails are often repairable without much expense.
• Fence Age – If the fence is relatively new, repairs can extend its lifespan without the need for replacement. Wood fences generally last 15-20 years, while PVC, chain link, and ornamental fences can last 25-35 years.
• Isolated Damage – When damage is limited to one section, such as a bent rail on a chain link fence, repairs are often simpler and more economical.

If you’re unsure, Paramount Fence offers free consultations to assess the best approach. Learn more about their fencing services here.

When to Replace a Fence

Replacing a fence becomes a better choice when damage is extensive, or if the fence is nearing the end of its life.

• Extensive Damage – When damage affects a large portion of the fence, replacement is often more practical. Structural issues from widespread decay or impact damage can compromise the fence’s stability.
• Aging Fences – Older fences nearing the end of their lifespan may require frequent repairs. Replacing them provides a more reliable, long-lasting solution, especially for wood fences over 15 years old or PVC and chain link fences over 25 years.
• Aesthetic and Functional Upgrades – Replacing a fence can enhance curb appeal and functionality. Paramount Fence offers styles like wood, ornamental, PVC/Vinyl and chain link, which can refresh your property’s appearance.

Cost Comparison – Repair vs. Replacement

While repairs are usually less costly in the short term, replacement may offer greater value over time, particularly if your fence requires frequent maintenance.

• Short-Term vs. Long-Term Cost – Repair costs add up, especially for older fences needing repeated fixes. For fences past their prime, replacement often saves time and money.
• Longevity – A new fence offers long-term durability with minimal upkeep. Paramount Fence offers special financing options to make it easier to replace an aging fence affordably.

Paramount Fence – Expertise and Quality You Can Trust

Locally owned and committed to serving Chicagoland, Illinois residents, Paramount Fence provides expert installation and replacement services. With more than a century’s worth of industry experience, our team is ready to meet with you to discuss your fencing needs, offering free estimates and customized solutions.

We strive to provide excellent customer service, which is why we have been members of the American Fence Association for almost 20 years and members of the local Chicagoland Chapter of the Better Business Bureau (BBB) for almost 20 years. In fact, we have one of the highest customer service ratings with the Better Business Bureau in the area. For more information, visit our website or speak with us at 630-239-2714.